Heavy Bearing Damage Analysis: Subsurface Spalling, Electrical Fluting & Fretting

Spalling, fluting and fretting patterns provide investigation clues. Establishing the cause requires operating history, mounting and lubrication checks, measurements and any necessary specialist examination; a photograph alone is insufficient.

Illustrative inspection methods. The applicable procedure, acceptance criteria and available reporting must be agreed for the supplied parts or investigation.

Ultrasonic flaw detection station surrounded by precision-ground heavy bearing outer rings with W33 grooves in ZQM Bearings workshop
Illustrative inspection methods. The applicable procedure, acceptance criteria and available reporting must be agreed for the supplied parts or investigation.

ISO 15243 Heavy Bearing Damage Classification & Field Signatures

Spalling, fluting and fretting patterns provide investigation clues. Establishing the cause requires operating history, mounting and lubrication checks, measurements and any necessary specialist examination; a photograph alone is insufficient.

Subsurface Fatigue Spalling

  • Sharp-edged craters flaking out along the loaded raceway zone
  • Initiated at subsurface shear stress peaks (typically 0.1–0.5 mm deep)
  • Drivers: chronic overload, low oil viscosity, or non-metallic steel inclusions
  • Corrective check: verify Cr/C0r safety factor + ultrasonic ring UT screening

Electrical Fluting (Washboarding)

  • Parallel burnished ridges spaced evenly around inner and outer raceways
  • Micro-arcing EDM craters caused by VFD shaft-to-ground stray current
  • Produces distinct high-frequency whine and dark oxide discoloration
  • Corrective check: install shaft grounding brushes or insulated bearing housings

Fretting Corrosion & False Brinelling

  • Reddish-brown iron-oxide (Fe2O3) or dark powder along bore/housing seats
  • Occurs from micro-slip on loose shaft fits or stationary machine vibration
  • Leads to oval housing distortion and accelerated secondary raceway cracking
  • Check measured shaft and housing seats against the approved drawing, fit specification and geometric tolerances

Edge Loading & Misalignment Smearing

  • Asymmetric wear track shifted steeply toward one raceway shoulder
  • Triggered by choked C0/C2 radial clearance or non-parallel roll-neck chocks
  • Rapid cage pocket scoring from skewed cylindrical or tapered rollers
  • Corrective check: evaluate C3/C4 clearance & re-bore deformed chock seats
Deep subsurface fatigue spalling crater on a heavy industrial bearing raceway
1. Fatigue Spalling: Rough-edged subsurface fatigue crater along the loaded raceway track.
Periodic washboard electrical fluting grooves caused by VFD shaft currents
2. Electrical Fluting: Parallel washboard-like ridges generated by repeated VFD shaft-current arcing.
Reddish-brown iron-oxide fretting corrosion band inside a loose bearing bore
3. Bore Fretting Corrosion: Reddish-brown oxide wear band caused by micro-slip between inner ring and shaft.

Diagnostic Matrix: Symptom → Root Cause → Corrective Specification

Use the matrix below during maintenance teardown reviews to convert physical bearing evidence into actionable procurement corrections:

Observed Raceway / Seat EvidencePrimary Failure MechanismImmediate Mechanical VerificationRecommended Specification Upgrade
Deep, sharp-bordered spalls centered in load zoneSubsurface rolling contact fatigueCheck actual vs. calculated L10h load & oil viscosity indexUpgrade to higher-capacity series (e.g. 223 Series / 23248 CA/W33) + UT-screened rings
Periodic grey corrugated grooves + burnt grease odorVFD shaft voltage / electrical erosionMeasure shaft-to-frame voltage on inverter drive endCombine shaft earthing + coated/ceramic-insulated mounting solution per drawing
Reddish rust-colored paste inside bore or outer seatFretting corrosion from micro-slipMicrometer check of shaft journal ovality and taperRe-machine worn journal; verify tight interference fit & radial clearance C3
Mirror-bright smear track on one shoulder + fractured ribsThermal preload or axial bind (misalignment)Check floating-bearing housing slide freedom & shaft expansionUse true floating NU cylindrical roller (NJ326EM only for one-direction locating) or spherical self-aligning units
Dull matte gray raceway with fine multi-pit frostingLubrication film collapse / micropittingSample oil for ISO cleanliness & water contaminationConfirm W33 central groove alignment + raise EP oil viscosity / relubrication interval
Diagnostic correlations aligned with ISO 15243 failure taxonomy and heavy-machinery maintenance audits.
WALE rotary roundness and raceway surface roughness analyzer measuring a heavy roller bearing ring inside ZQM metrology lab
Automated roundness and surface profile measurement checking raceway waviness and contact geometry limits.

How Factory UT Screening & Raceway Profiling Prevent Premature Spalling

Methods that may support a bearing investigation include ultrasonic inspection and dimensional or surface measurements. The available inspection scope, equipment, procedures and reports for a particular order must be confirmed; these methods do not by themselves establish a unique failure cause.

  • Ultrasonic Flaw Detection (UT): High-frequency acoustic scanning screens heavy ring cross sections—such as thick-walled Series 231/232 and four-row rolling mill FCDP rings—to reject internal voids or macro-inclusions along the subsurface Hertzian shear zone before expensive finish grinding begins.
  • Rotary Roundness & Surface Roughness Profiling: Automated form testers trace circularity, harmonic lobing (waviness), and Ra raceway surface roughness to preserve an unbroken elastohydrodynamic (EHL) oil film under slow heavy rotation.
  • Controlled Radial Clearance Grouping: Particularly on 23080 CA/W33 (400 × 600 × 148 mm) and heavy crusher shafts, verifying residual clearance after interference fit stops premature thermal lockup during first run-in hours.

4-Point Pre-Order Failure Investigation Checklist

  • Document Teardown Photos & Load Zone Location: Measure whether spalling tracks the static housing load zone (radial overload) or follows shaft imbalance (rotating unbalance).
  • Log Actual Radial Fit & Housing Ovality: Measure housing bore in two perpendicular axes at both ends before installing any replacement 24056 CA/W33 or cylindrical roller unit.
  • Verify VFD & Earth Continuity: Always rule out stray shaft voltage on inverter-fed fan, pump, and mill motors prior to ordering standard steel replacement bearings.
  • Specify Matching Clearance & W33 Supply: Confirm C0, C3, or C4 radial internal clearance plus whether an anti-rotation dowel or W33 lubrication pin is required.

Investigating Repeat Bearing Failures on Critical Equipment?

Send teardown measurements, current bearing code, and operating speed/lubrication notes to ZQM engineers to lock in a failure-resistant replacement specification.

Consult Failure & Selection Team

Scroll to Top